If you’ve ever found yourself debating whether a Roof Top Tent (RTT) is the right choice for your overlanding or camping adventures, you’re not alone. Many outdoor enthusiasts, from seasoned travelers to weekend warriors, wrestle with this decision. RTTs are marketed as the ultimate in convenience and comfort, but are they truly all they’re cracked up to be? Or, as some overlanders have privately admitted, is it more like owning a boat—the two best days being the day you buy it and the day you sell it?
In this article, we’ll take a deep dive into the pros and cons of Roof Top Tents (RTTs), based on real user experiences, to help you make an informed decision on whether an RTT is the right fit for you.
What Makes Roof Top Tents So Appealing?
One of the biggest selling points of RTTs is their ease of setup and take down. Many overlanders enjoy the quickness with which these tents can be deployed—usually taking just minutes to open up. This convenience is a huge factor for those who don’t want to spend hours each day setting up camp. Additionally, RTTs keep you off the ground, which can be a major advantage in areas prone to dampness, uneven terrain, or pesky wildlife. The added comfort of sleeping higher up, away from wet or rocky ground, makes RTTs particularly appealing to older adventurers or those looking for a little extra luxury.
For some, RTTs are an absolute game-changer, providing a sense of security and comfort that traditional ground tents simply can’t offer. The memory foam mattresses found in many models add to the comfort, ensuring you can sleep soundly after a long day of hiking or driving.
The Drawbacks: Not All It's Cracked Up to Be?
However, RTTs aren’t perfect for everyone. For starters, they can be a bit cumbersome. While they’re convenient to set up, they often require a ladder for access, which can be a hassle in the middle of the night if you need to answer nature’s call. Some RTT users have expressed frustration with the height of their tents, particularly on larger vehicles, making it difficult to store gear or pack things away without climbing up and down.
Another drawback is the lack of mobility. Unlike ground tents, which can be easily moved to different areas within a campsite, RTTs tie you to the top of your vehicle. Once set up, it can be a pain to pack up if you want to explore the area during the day. This has led some overlanders to keep a backup ground tent for situations where they want to break camp temporarily without dismantling the RTT.
Additionally, there’s the matter of weight and wind resistance. While RTTs are designed to withstand the elements, some users have voiced concerns about the stability of their tents in strong winds. This is particularly true for soft-shell RTTs, which can feel a bit unstable during storms or when gusts are particularly strong. For some, the added weight on top of their vehicle also impacts fuel efficiency and handling, making it less ideal for those who frequently travel on challenging trails.
Is It Worth the Investment?
The cost of a high-quality RTT is a major consideration. With prices ranging from $1,500 to $3,000, RTTs are a significant investment, and not everyone feels the purchase is worth it after a few seasons of use. As one user described, the purchase of an RTT felt a bit like buying an expensive shotgun—something that seemed like a great idea at the time but ultimately didn’t get as much use as expected.
That said, if you’re someone who enjoys overlanding in areas with challenging terrain or inclement weather, an RTT could be a game-changer. The convenience of sleeping off the ground, combined with the quick setup and added comfort, might make it worth every penny.
Who Should Buy a Roof Top Tent?
If you’re someone who often camps in rainy or damp conditions, or if you frequently find yourself in areas without perfect flat ground, an RTT might be exactly what you need. Overlanders in mountainous regions or places with unpredictable weather will benefit from the extra protection RTTs provide against moisture and uneven terrain.
For families or those traveling with multiple people, an RTT may not always be the best choice. Many families prefer the extra space provided by larger ground tents, which can accommodate more people and gear. Additionally, if you’re someone who likes to move campsites regularly, an RTT may limit your flexibility compared to a traditional tent that can be pitched just about anywhere.
Our Final Thoughts
Choosing between an RTT and a ground tent comes down to your camping style and needs. RTTs offer comfort, convenience, and protection from the elements, but they’re not for everyone. They’re ideal for solo travelers or couples who don’t need a ton of extra space and enjoy staying put for extended periods. For others, a ground tent may still be the way to go—providing more mobility, space, and versatility.
If you’re still on the fence, the best advice is to test it out. Many RTT dealers allow you to demo tents, so take advantage of this opportunity to see if an RTT fits your needs. Additionally, talking to fellow overlanders at events or reading through online forums can help you get a feel for the pros and cons based on real-world experience.
At the end of the day, an RTT isn’t just a purchase; it’s an investment in your overlanding lifestyle. If it enhances your experiences and fits your needs, it’s worth it. But if it doesn’t, don’t be afraid to go back to what works best for you—whether that’s a traditional ground tent or another form of shelter.
Join the Conversation
We’d love to hear your thoughts on RTTs. Have you made the leap? Are you considering one? What’s your experience? Join us in the discussion, and let’s help each other make more informed decisions about the gear we choose for our overlanding adventures!